Stone Coated Steel Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles- Which is Best for Your Roof in Mansfield, TX?

Related Posts

Roof Structural Repair: Signs, Process and When to Call

Learn how roof structural repair differs from surface repair, which warning signs point to damaged framing or decking, and what a proper assessment involves.

Roofing Contractor in Texas: How to Choose and Verify One

How to pick a roofing contractor in Texas: what to verify, the insurance rules that protect you, what a contract must say, and how to compare bids.

Roof Insurance Claim: How to File and Get Paid

How a roof insurance claim works: what is covered, what to check in your policy, how to file, how payments are paid and what to do if you are denied.

Peeling Exterior Paint: Find the Cause Before You Repaint

Peeling exterior paint is usually a water problem. Learn how to trace the source, prep the surface correctly and repaint so the new coat lasts.

PVC Roof Repair: Methods, Costs and When to Replace

How PVC roof repair works: common failures, heat-weld patching steps, US cost ranges, repair vs. replacement, and insurance basics for Texas property owners.

Roof Nail Pops: Causes, Risks and How Roofers Fix Them

Nail pops are fasteners backing out of your roof deck. Learn what causes them, when they lead to leaks, what repair costs and when to call a roofer.

Choosing a Dallas County Roofing Contractor in 2026

How to choose a roofing contractor in Dallas County: permits by city, vetting steps, what an estimate and contract should say, storm claims, and upkeep.

Siding Repair Cost: What You’ll Pay and What Changes the Price

Siding repair usually costs a few hundred to a couple thousand dollars. See price ranges by material, what drives quotes, and when insurance or replacement makes sense.

Hail Damage Roof: Signs, Inspection, Repair and Claims

Learn how to spot hail damage on a roof, what an inspection checks, when repair or replacement makes sense, and how Texas insurance claims work.

Industrial Roof Coating: Types, Prep and When It Fits

How industrial roof coatings work, how acrylic, silicone, polyurethane and asphalt compare, what prep and curing need, and when to coat, repair or replace.

Your roof is one of the most important parts of your living space and it covers the largest asset you own, so it is important to choose the best material for your roof. One of the most common questions we are asked is about stone coated steel roofing vs. asphalt shingles – which is best for your roof in Mansfield, TX? If you have similar questions read on to get the answer.

You will have many choices available to you when it comes the right roofing material for your home or office. Many people find themselves trying to select between asphalt shingles and stone coated steel roofing. Each of them has its own advantages and disadvantages, here in this blog we will explore all of these pros and cons for each, provided by a certified asphalt and stone coated steel roofing contractor in Mansfield, TX.

Costs Comparison Stone Coated Steel Roofing Vs. Asphalt Shingles

The cost of roofing material is usually calculated by measuring it in squares. A square equals 100 square feet. The average cost for stone coated steel roofing in Mansfield, TX is $800-$1200 per square. When comparing it with asphalt shingles you will find stone coated steel roofing is more expensive, it may cost roughly double the price of a standard shingle roof. So why even consider stone coated steel roofing?  Keep on reading….

Installation process of Stone Coated Steel Roofing and Asphalt Shingles 

c3f7vc5crtt.2309251525476

The time required for installation of both roofing systems will vary depending on roof planes and pitches.  However, overall, the installation of both types of shingles will be similar.

Some roofers will make the argument that asphalt shingles install faster, but that is sometimes since they are not used to working with stone coated steel roofing system. Either way, this point can be a tossup between the two types of shingles and is hard to exactly determine a winner.

Durability of roofing material – Stone Coated Steel vs Asphalt Shingles

The average lifespan of asphalt shingles is about 20 years at winds of 60 to 120 mph. asphalt shingles provide your home with good protection at a fraction of the price of other types of roofing materials. On the other hand, stone coated steel shingles are strong, flexible, and they can last up to 40 years or even longer.

The main component with lifespan and durability of both roofing systems is the materials that are used in their manufacturing. Asphalt shingles may be durable, but they are not made from materials that eventually break down; they are not made from metal!

Stone Coated Steel Roofing Vs. Asphalt Shingles Maintenance

Asphalt shingles are designed to lay on top of each other that’s why over time you will begin to see roof issues as the shingles begin to break, crack, or lose their texture.  They may begin letting moisture into your attic as they age.

Stone coated metal shingles, on the other hand, are made of metal, so these shingles will not warp, break, or crack. They can also be cleaned more easily since you can wash them.

Environment-friendly Roofing System

Standard asphalt shingles create a lot of waste. When you get your asphalt roof replaced, most of the shingles end up in landfills. asphalt shingles contain materials that can cause health risks when they are broken down, burned, or being handled by roofers.

Stone coated metal roofing, on the other hand, is made of metal, so the impact on the environment is quite different. Because they are made of metal, the parts can be made from recycled metal. Better yet, when a metal roof is being replaced, you can recycle all the old shingles so that they can be used again! So, asphalt shingles may be cheaper, but metal shingles are a clear win for the environment.

James Kate Roofing & solar can help you choose the best roofing material

If you are still not sure about the roofing material that you should choose, get in touch with James Kate Roofing & solar our experienced Southlake roofing experts will help you choose the best roof. Schedule your free initial roof inspection and discover how our skilled crews and legendary service will make all the difference in your roof.